Organ sale legality essay 1051 words | 5 pages legalizing the sale of human organs every 10 minutes, another person is added to the waiting list for an organ transplant. Although, once it is legal to buy and sell organs in the united states, it will be difficult to prevent sales across borders kidney for sale by owner: human organs, transplantation and the market washington, dc: georgetown university press 2005 18 taylor js. As a further work on this issue, the article “sales of kidneys prompt new law and debate” from the book “topics for today” (smith and mare, 2004) continues providing an insight into the controversy over legalization of commercial transactions in human organs, specially, kidneys.
The iranians have solved their kidney shortage by legalizing sales many will protest that an organ market will lead to exploitation and unfair advantages for the rich and powerful. The big topic question that still causes the biggest arguments is whether to legalize the sale of human organs should the selling of organs become legal, if it is mostly coming for the poor the effects of this could be a major issue, the industry is taking advantage of the poor and this could be a major issue. Therefore i, as an intelligent intellectual who happens to care for the future of this world, will opt against legalizing the sale of human organs and if you have any common sense you will do the same. By legalizing the sale of human organs, there is a greater chance of increasing organ supply and decreasing the number of lives lost according to the national organ transplant act of 1984, the buying and selling or compensation for organs from any human for the purpose of transplantation is illegal (linde.
It was concluded that legalize the sales of human organs can not make more people get rescue and the sale of human organs is a kind of crime the recommendations are that organ sales should be banned and society needs a law to control the black market. Many ethical and trusting individuals like you, who advocate for buying organs, resolve the undoubted reality of abuse of the poor by the rich by using the reassuring words ‘safe and legal’ it is easy to minimize the conceptual consequences using words but so much harder in reality. Suppose we get the government to get into this organ sale purchase thing and have a “system” which means there is a “framework” in which we take good care of the donor and the recipient like the government has when it deals with financial matters like taxes and education and healthcare spending.
Like all prohibitions, restrictions on organ sales have created a huge black market black market kidneys average a selling price of $260,000 in the united states and $62,000 in china. In the united states, for example, the 1984 national organ transplantation act prohibits the sale of human organs by both live donors and by the families of the recently deceased (weekes n p) many developing nations have likewise banned the commercial trading of human organs. Legalizing the sale of organs would increase the number of americans that travel to developing nations in search of cheap human organs, motivating the poor to turn to organ harvesting for financial refuge. People agree to give their organs to brokers because they have no choice as the sale of human organs is not legalized in the majority of the countries the legalization of the sale of human organs and creation of regulated system can eliminate those unregulated “black market” with their unfair brokers, claims keizai (2001. Legalizing the sale of human organs every 10 minutes, another person is added to the waiting list for an organ transplant that’s 144 people every day, 52,620 people every year and every day, 18 people die because there aren’t enough organs to go around.
An opposing case of the matter of selling human organs would be making the sale of organs legal in the united sates as well as around the world rob lawler explains it something like this we should accept that we all form one body. Legalizing the sale of human organs this essay will argue that a legal – albeit highly regulated – market for the sale of human organs provides an ethically sound and practically feasible solution to this problem it can be seen from the above discussion that a legal market for the sale of human organs is the most ethical and. Organ trade is the trade of human organs, tissues or other body parts, usually for transplantation there is a global need or demand for healthy body parts for transplantation, far exceeding the numbers available. Worst of all, the ban encourages an international black market, where desperate people do end up selling their organs, without protection, fair compensation or proper medical care continue.
Side one: selling human organs should be legal if legalized, a market would allow licensed professionals to evaluate donor-patient compatibility the amount of americans waiting for a transplant outnumbers the amount of donors by about four to one. The hidden cost of organ sale download the paper the hidden cost of organ sale american journal of transplantation, 6(7) 1524-1529 but legalized kidney sale might have the very opposite effect if you want health insurance, sell your organ kidney for sale by owner: human organs, transplantation, and the market washington, dc. Through consistent refusal to legalize the human organ sale market, many homeless and poor people from developing countries are falling prey to merchants of human organs to satisfy increasing demand in the black market. Human organs essay the market of human organs is one that lives in the shadows the selling of organs is currently illegal in every developed country although a black market is prevalent throughout the world.